Gay High School
Santi said on August 9, 2003 16:07:
I read on the news the other day that they’re opening a Gay High School in New York City next fall, where just can go bisexuals, lesbians and gays.
Well, I just wanted to know what’s your opinion on this issue and hopefully start a nice discussion about it.
Isn’t this promoting segregation?
LittleSpooky said on August 9, 2003 18:32:
Here, this is from my friend in Las Vegas, Nevada:
Imagine waking one morning to a world in which your family is not like you and relationships are not like yours. The public image of romance and love is not like yours. You have been raised believing
that people like you are revolting, immoral, sick and even evil even though you know you did not choose your sexual orientation. Imagine that what you see in the media is not reflective of your life.
Picture yourself in a world in which you are subject to verbal and even physical abuse because of how you were born, and imagine that you are denied the same rights and treatment enjoyed by your peers.
Imagine that you could be kicked out of your house, lose your job or your house, or even your life because of who you are. Worst of all, see yourself loving someone dearly yet having to hide that love from the world because you might face rejection from family, friends, church, and state. Imagine having to pretend to be what you are not,
having to lie to the world daily.
This is the world gay, lesbian and bisexual persons find themselves in each day. Would you choose this life if you didn’t have to do so? Gays and lesbians do not choose to be gay or lesbian. Gays and
lesbians must overcome tremendous obstacles as they live their life and seek rights such as life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.
Why are so many gay persons “coming out?” For many it is because they are tired of this kind of life and they are fighting for equality. They have had enough of the oppression, violence, lack of
equality, lying, and forced secrecy and shame. They refuse to live the life of a victim. They have had enough of being second class citizens and know they deserve the same rights and responsibilities held by those persons who are not gay or lesbian.
If you think gays, lesbians and bisexuals choose their sexual orientation, ask yourself when you chose yours. If you are heterosexual did you wake one morning and decide that you were going
to fall in love with someone of the opposite sex? Did you decide that you would be attracted to the opposite sex? Did someone recruit you as a heterosexual? Gays, lesbians and bisexuals do not choose their orientation any more than do heterosexuals. Studies consistently demonstrate that the problems gays face are caused by
the attitudes and behaviors of society at large, not by sexual orientation.
———————————————————————
Some Definitions:
CLOSETED: Not disclosing one’s sexual orientation. A person could be in the closet with him/herself or could be in the closet with other people all the time or only in certain situations. An openly gay, or
out, person is one who is comfortable with his/her sexuality and does does not hide from other people that he/she is gay or lesbian. There is nothing shameful about being in the closet and no one should ever come out until ready to do so.
STRAIGHT: Heterosexual
COMING OUT: The process, often lifelong, in which a person acknowledges, accepts, and appreciates his/her sexual orientation as being gay or bisexual. This may eventually involve sharing of this
information with other persons. Coming out takes tremendous courage and should not be attempted without support.
HOMOPHOBIA: The fear and hatred of those who love and desire persons of the same sex. It includes prejudice, discrimination, harassment,
and acts of violence.
HETEROSEXISM: The system of advantages bestowed upon heterosexual persons. It assumes that all persons are, or should be, heterosexual
and therefore excludes the needs, concerns and life experiences of persons who are gay.
FAMILY of CHOICE: Since their biological family rejects many gay persons, many will create a support network that serves the role of family.
ALLY: A heterosexual person who supports and honors diversity of sexual orientation and who acts to interrupt and challenge homophobia and heterosexism
BIOLOGICAL SEX: Determined by chromosomes, hormones, etc. (Male/female)
GENDER IDENTITY: A person’s innermost feeling of being male or female. Most, but not all, people have a gender identity that matches their biological sex. Gender identity is probably determined between the age of 18 months and three years, if not even earlier. This identity has nothing to do with being gay or straight. In fact, most gay men feel like they are men and most lesbians feel like they are women.
GENDER ROLE: The socially defined roles and behaviors assigned to males and females. This can vary over time and place. Masculine/Feminine.
SEXUAL ORIENTATION: Determined by whom we are attracted to and fall in love with. It is probably influenced by genetics, hormones, brain differences, and environmental factors and is almost certainly set by birth or within the first 3-5 years of life. Sexual orientation almost certainly cannot be changed. A person might, however, learn to behave in ways inconsistent with his/her orientation though most psychologists find this very unhealthy. A person can only choose to be true or false to whom he/she is.
The APA (American Psychological Association) defines sexual orientation as “an enduring emotional, romantic, sexual or affectional attraction to another person. It is easily distinguished
from other components of sexuality including biological sex, gender identity (the psychological sense of being male or female) and the
social gender role (adherence to cultural norms for feminine and masculine behavior)...Sexual orientation is different from sexual behavior because it refers to feelings and self-concept. Persons may or may not express their sexual orientation in their behaviors.” The APA goes on to state “There are numerous theories about the origins of a person’s sexual orientation; most scientists today agree that sexual orientation is most likely the result of a complex interaction
of environmental, cognitive and biological factors.
In most people, sexual orientation is shaped at an early age. There is also considerable recent evidence to suggest that biology, including genetic or inborn hormonal factors, play a significant role
in a person’s sexuality.” The APA also report that “although we can choose whether to act on our feelings, psychologists do not consider sexual orientation to be a conscious choice that can be voluntarily changed.” It also states that “the reality is that homosexuality is not an illness. It does not require treatment and is not changeable.”
———————————————————————-
Some Myths:
“I don’t know any persons who are gay.” FACT: You may not know any persons who are out to you as being gay. In a classroom of 30 persons, for instance, there are probably 2-3 persons who are gay.
Estimates are that 1 person out of 10 is gay. Using one widely accepted estimate, there may be over 20 million gay or lesbian persons in the United States alone.
“Being gay is a form of illness.” FACT: The American Psychological Association says, “It is no more abnormal or sick to be gay than to be left-handed. There is, in fact, a growing body of evidence to indicate that sexual orientation is determined before birth by some combination of genetic and biological events. Since it is not an
illness, it needs, nor has, no cure.
“Gay persons are child molesters and recruit children to their lifestyle.” FACT: By far, the majority of child molesters are heterosexual men. The National Center on Child Abuse and Neglect in
the Department of Health, Education and Welfare, found that over 90% of all child abuse is committed by straight men on minor females.
Furthermore, one does not choose to be gay just as one does not choose to be straight. One only decides whether to act on his/her orientation.
“Men who are gay and women who are lesbians want to be the opposite sex or have simply not found the right person.” FACT: Almost all of the males enjoy being men and almost all of the women enjoy being women. They simply are attracted to, and fall in love with, persons
of their same sex.
“Persons who are gay cannot maintain long-term relationships.” FACT: Just like heterosexual people, persons who are gay form a variety of relationships that last a short time or many years. Heterosexuals even have a divorce rate of 50% while nobody knows about the length of relationships of gay persons since they are not allowed to marry.
“People who are gay could change if they wanted to do so.” FACT: Almost all studies show that no one, gay or straight, can change their sexual orientation. Our orientation is almost certainly
determined sometime between conception and the first years of life. Gay and straight people might be able to change their behavior but not their underlying orientation. We do not, however, choose our sexual orientation. Dr. George Weinberg writes in Society and the Healthy Homosexual, “From what I have seen, the harm to the homosexual man or woman done by the person’s trying to convert is mutifold...First of all, the venture is almost certain to fail...In trying to convert, you will deepen your belief that you are one of nature’s misfortunes.”
“Persons who are gay do not understand how to make a good family.” FACT: One in every four families has a gay or lesbian person within that family several studies suggest. Studies also show that there is no difference between gay and straight persons in their quality or ability to care, love or raise children.
“Persons who are gay are protected and granted equal rights.” FACT: Only a few states and a few cities and organizations include gay persons in their policies of nondiscrimination. Gay persons are not
allowed to get married, are not given the same financial rights as straight couples, do not have to be allowed in to see their partner who is ill in a hospital and so forth.
“You can identify someone as being gay or lesbian by their mannerisms or physical characteristics.” FACT: Gay people are as diverse as are straight persons. Only a small percentage of gay persons fit the stereotypes.
“In a gay relationship, one person plays the husband (butch) and the other plays the wife (femme) role.” FACT: Since laws, churches and
society have typically condemned, or at least ignored, the relationships of gay persons, most gay persons do not feel an obligation to follow “the rules” of what a relationship is to look like. Most gays and lesbians, therefore, create very different
relationships based on equality and who each person is, rather than upon societal roles. In fact, since most gay and lesbian persons run their relationships without a model, the look of each relationship varies greatly from that of other relationships.
“Gay and lesbian persons are promiscuous.” FACT: Some are and some aren’t, just as the same can be said for straight persons.
“Being gay or lesbian is something new.” FACT: Homosexuality appears across time and place, and even across animal species. In a 1951 study by Ford and Beach, they found even then that many cultures consider homosexuality a normal variation of sexual behavior.
———————————————————————-
Miscellaneous:
Though scientists do not know for certain, much of the research suggests that people may be born with their sexual orientation or that orientation is set by a very young age. People do not have a
choice as to whether they are gay or straight or bisexual. The only real choice appears to be in whether or not we live out who we are, or pretend to be what we are not.
Most responsible research suggests that people cannot change their sexual orientation, but that some people can change their behaviors–
at a price.
Most people do not one day wake up to say, “I’m gay.” Sexual orientation is something we discover about ourselves over time. If you aren’t sure if you are gay, lesbian, bisexual or straight, don’t worry. It takes time to sort out our feelings and all the
information we have about who we are. One day you will know which gender you are attracted to: the same (gay or lesbian), both (bisexual), or the opposite (straight).
If you think you might be gay or lesbian you may find it helpful to learn more about sexual orientation. You may also find it useful to talk with someone you trust who is also knowledeable. Most of all, though, you will need to pay attention to what your body, mind and heart are telling you over time. You probably do not have to have sex to know if you are gay or straight. Sexual orientation is one part of who we are rather than how we behave.
Gay men do not want to be women. they like being male. Lesbians do not want to be men. they like being female. Sexual orientation has nothing to do with gender identification. Persons who are gay are
emotionally and physically attracted to members of the same gender.
They are not attracted to all members of that gender just as straight people are not attracted to all members of the opposite sex.
You cannot tell who is gay or straight by looking at a person. There are plenty of effeminate gay men and straight men. There are plenty of masculine gay and straight men. The same is true of lesbians. You cannot know for sure if a person is gay or lesbian unless that person tells you truthfully.
“Imagine that”
Denstandigaresan said on August 9, 2003 19:33:
Then wouldn’t it be fair to open a school just for straight people... fat people... ’nerds’ etc etc etc...
My best friend is gay, and he thinks this is balls as much as I do... he doesn’t want to be shut away in a ’gay’ only world... he wants to be accepted... and there is no way that will happen as long as this kind of thing goes ahead!
I had SO much more hurt and pain at school, and now... because I am fat. My friend is gay, and he is accepted better than I am. Oy!
Roxlander said on August 9, 2003 21:17:
LittleSpooky, thanks for that information, it’s very complete. I’m gonna print it and show it to some people I know who are so ignorant. I have to translate it first, but I hope it helps. I totally agree with every word.
And I also agree with Denstandigaresan’s friend. There is no need to make a different world for gays, this planet is everybody’s home, and everybody is free to live their life whenever, wherever and however they want.
So I think a place like that high school would only promote segregation.
B-Any-1-U-Wanna-B right here and right now!!!
richkoni said on August 9, 2003 23:21:
the story is sooo blown up by the media... the school only gets more money because they spend extra attention to gays and the acceptation of them (according to the dutch COC) i think that that is really good cause there are a lot of problems for gays in schools... both students and teachers...
kachina008 said on August 10, 2003 10:18:
in a sense, a gay high school *does*serve to segregate, but what choice do they have in a society that is so openly homophobic?
I live in holland, and I asked a friend of mine if he was going to the Gay Pride in Amsterdam. he said, no, why should I? I don’t need to show the world I am rebelling, I don’t see a “straight parade”..I have no need to stand up for myself.
That really opened my eyes to the fact that while a lot of countries are totally ok with homosexuality, others are not. And sadly, USA is one of those who is not. I know gay people in the states, and my poor friends have to call their partners “room mates”. gay pride parades and gay high schools is necessitated by the closed minds of people and government of these countries.
And I think that is sad. As a straight person, I admit I have a lot to learn about the gay lifestyle. but I do know that I am ready to accept people as they come, coz everyone deserves the basic respect as a human being rite?
ugh. homophobicity and closemindedness sickens me.
derek said on August 10, 2003 12:15:
i believe that this gay school is not a good idea it may only lead to problems by the close minded people and aggrivation by others that just do not understand the needs of other peole than themselves.i dont care what a person is we all have a right to live the way we choose.also segegation can cause untold problems like it has in the past .i may not think its a good idea but if it can help the issure then im for it
derek said on August 10, 2003 12:18:
littlespooky .that was a great letter from your friend i hope it opens a lot of peoples eyes
richkoni said on August 10, 2003 15:29:
well for the once living in holland thinking that we have no problems with gays on highschools just read a report from the schoolinspectie!! no problems?!?! don’t keep ignoring things out of so-called or wished tollerance!!
derek said on August 10, 2003 19:20:
@Richkoni.sure we have problems here as well.and we dont close our eyes at least i dont but Holland seems to accept the problem more than other parts of the world so what is your point?
kachina008 said on August 11, 2003 08:58:
richkoni, i don’t know the situation, i work in the university, and i have only been here for a year. I am not ignoring anything. instead of being so hostile, maybe you should talk about the point and enlighten me/us?
Echoes_of_a_Doubt said on August 11, 2003 11:36:
Little Spooky:
Coming from Utah, the LDS State, how are Gays treated over in Utah?? I know that the LDS Church is very homophobic. Do you have any Gay Clubs or Bars in SLC?
StillFar said on August 11, 2003 16:06:
Interesting. Can you imagine all the money they will have to spend on security in the bathrooms? Seriously, the contradiction is that they offer a school like that in New York, where you already have advantages growing up gay. The bigger the city, the easier it is to have a normal life as a gay. Here in Montreal, we have a complete district dedicated to the gay community. There are gay lawyers, gay doctors, gay pet stores, gay bars,…basically you can spend 24/7 within the same area, there’s nothing you can’t get in the district. When I came here, I thought it’s great…so many men, so little time, all of them sharing my lifestyle. Well, today I rarely go there, it’s a ghetto and I’m just so sick of it. It separates you from the world and changes your visions…
I don’t think it’s good for a teenager to be in a very gay environment such as this school!
However I think that every school should have a straight/gay/bi/trans alliance!
@kachina: I don’t agree with your friend. Going to the parade isn’t about yourself. People who join pride are usually out already and found their space in society. We go to the parade (or we should) to help those who are not in Amsterdam, New York or Sydney. Even in the Netherlands, if you go to the countryside, you will find loads of gays stuggling with their sexuality and homophoby...I do think that there’s a reason for him to go to the parade!
m-cvk said on August 11, 2003 17:39:
I think it’s sad that it has to go this far. I don’t understand why gay people are being treated like this. I don’t think this is a solution. I hope the students at this school will be happy and hopefully they have a place where they can feel and show who they are and won’t be judged for that.
I’m not gay, but some of my friends are. For me, there’s no difference.
All the best to the people who are in a tough situation because they just love someone from the same sex. Remember: love is all!
CU,
MC
coyboyusa said on August 11, 2003 19:06:
its gonna end up in scandal cause things like that always do...i dont see how segregating us from one another is gonna make the world any better...why dont we EDUCATE the naive straight students to understand gays instead of moving fags away from them
Anarem said on August 12, 2003 02:03:
@Little Spooky: Great letter!
@Santi: Wonderful topic!
I’m for schools like this– if a gay kid wants to go to school freely and openly without fear of getting beaten up or harrassed, then he or she should have this school as an option. If there are schools for the gifted and talented, and schools for certain religions or languages, then why not schools for gay kids?
But personally, I don’t think I would have chosen such a school growing up, because I would have wanted to be with my friends, the majority of whom were straight. Also, ideally, in my opinion, high school gives a preview of what life after school is going to be like, where you learn how to cope with people from all different walks of life... I’m afraid that kids who get used to the warm cocoon of gay-only school will have a really skewed view of the world and thus not be prepared enough for its harsh realities.
LittleSpooky said on August 12, 2003 03:24:
Attendance at this school is NOT a mandatory thing. If you want to go, you can. If I was able to, and I am 100% heterosexual, I WOULD attend. I have no problems with that.
Utah... yes we do have some gay clubs here:
Trapp, right next door to the garage I work out of (I’m a bus driver)
Paper Moon and a few others. But those are the predominant ones. How are they treated in Utah. Well, they’re not widely accepted, however, I haven’t heard of any hate crimes pertaining to gays as opposed to gang bangers shooting each others, as well as innocents.
I work with SEVERAL gay men and women, drivers and supervisors alike. Some of my best friends at the job site are gay. Redcub (not his name) wants me to go out with him to a Gay Leather Club. I’m half tempted to take him up on it. Gotta email him and find out. Does this thought bother me? Nah. I trust him well :o)
coyboyusa said on August 12, 2003 19:37:
still far hit it right on the head...gays..especially young ones have lost sight of what pride means and the hurdles gays in gerneral have had to overcome
derek said on August 13, 2003 10:23:
good point Adam it certainly is provoking conversation which isnt a bad thing thats what is needed.all problems need to be talked about thats the only way to find the right solution. it is a touchy situation i myself do not care what a person is its his/her own choice.live and let live is what i say
StillFar said on August 13, 2003 12:56:
What if you think you are gay, so you go to this school, but then you realize that you aren’t, and you’re stuck in this school?
-adam, when you have you’re coming out, it’s a very hard step to do. I don’t think A LOT of people do that step without being really sure of who they are. If you decide to go to a school like that you should know if you’re gay or not (it’s usually not that difficult to realize). But let’s say that this person realizes that he or she is not gay...drop out of that school, what’s the problem?
Or what if you think you are gay, but really inside you are straight. And then you go to this school, and because there are no straight people of the opposite sex, you aren’t allowed to exercise or experiment with your “straightness”?
-I don’t know where you got this theory, but it sounds quite funny to me. You do realize that the gay lifestyle is connected to a more difficult time as a teenager...
What if you are straight, but you have two gay parents, who pressure you to go to this school?
-being gay has something to do with sexuality. Gays do have brains, you know. Gay parents I know don’t expect their kid to be gay, furthermore most of them don’t want their kid to be gay, so why should a gay parent send a straight kid to a gay school?
What if the “gay school” becomes a target of violence by gay-bashers - I mean, it puts all the gays in one place so the bashers have an easy target!
-maybe so, but from my experience gay bashers don’t really get violent in a gay environment. Besides, I guess they thought of some sort of security.
Do the teachers have to be gay? And what kind of teacher would teach there, anyway? Might that attract, shall we say, the “wrong kind” of teacher?
-the same problem applies to every regular school. Why do people still connect homosexuals with pedophiles.
And doesn’t this promote segregation?
- yes it does!
And isn’t it not even a “real” type of segregation, but a segregation based upon sexual practices?
-right
And isn’t it unfair that taxpayer money is being used to support a gay school, MANY American taxpayers who do not believe in that type of lifestyle, or in the least, want to financially support it?
-we all pay taxes for one or another institution we might not believe in. I don’t think 1 school will financially harm some closed minded people.
And finally, isn’t this sending the message to gay teens that they should run away from their problems? Shouldn’t they learn to co-exist in “straight society”?
-yeah, it gives the message that they should isolate their selves. And no, they should learn to create a ‘straight/gay society’.
StillFar said on August 13, 2003 18:38:
if your brother made that experience or knows of someone who was in fact straight but didn’t realize that he was straight...well, then I guess I’m uninformed, otherwise, it sounds just VERY unrealistic this way.
Santi said on August 19, 2003 20:52:
Well, but the point for this school is that there are real problems happening right now. Of course, in a more perfect world you could try to just make society accept gays like they are (especially this is difficult if they look very “gay”), but there are real people suffering real problems and this people just wants to help out a bit.
Besides, they don’t ask for information about sexual orientation to let the students enrol.
So, let’s be a little more constructive, what would you do if not this right now for these people? (living in 2003, New York, USA)
StillFar said on November 10, 2003 17:00:
ok, maybe they’re not getting the right education at that school ;)
http://uk.gay.com/headlines/5336
LittleSpooky said on August 9, 2003 17:48:
Yes it is. However, I’ll have to dig up an email that a friend of mine sent me (who is gay) and, while I have absolutely NO problems with gay men and women, this email opened my eyes further to the suffering and hardships these people face. I’m for the school, it may provide a “safe haven” for them. God knows they don’t get much help from soceity