The Daily Roxette discussions forum has been closed. The forum is only available as a read-only archive.
ATAY vs. ON
14 replies
BonBon said on July 24, 2003 15:50:
which one is better; A Thing About You or Opportunity Nox?
I give my vote for ATAY definitely.
cheers
Roxreporter said on July 24, 2003 17:06:
I love ATAY,
don’t like ON that much, it’s produced quite terrible and it’s waaayyyy to repetitive, certainly when you consider it only last for less than 3 minutes.
steven said on July 24, 2003 20:18:
A Thing About You is beautifully simplistic. A pleasure to listen to and in a different league to the very ordinary Opportunity Nox.
harriej said on July 25, 2003 21:23:
Depends on the mood your in. If you want to hear a ballad: ATAY is the best choice.
For uptempo-music ON is the best choice.
Not fair to compare.
However, If I have to do that, at this moment my vote goes to Opportunity NOx (but tomorrow it might be going to A thing about You).
Jackeill said on July 25, 2003 21:29:
right, you can’t compare uptempo with ballad. my vote goes to atay though. it has ’something’ in it.
Kecho said on July 27, 2003 09:08:
Nox is better than ATAY, but best song published in the last few months is Stay (AH,AW,AP)
PiterPam said on July 28, 2003 11:39:
ATAY is my favorite.
ON is good too. but I think it´s more commercial than a good RoxSong. There is nothing special in this song
Rox_Nox2003 said on July 24, 2003 16:02:
Nooooo the songs are both amazing to me it their own way ...it’s not fair to compare a beautiful ballad to a great high speed uptempo cool song....why do you say ATAY is better? Only because it was a bit more successful than ON? Please ....gimme a breake....listen to the music for a chenge and stop letting yourself being hipnothized by charts or sales....music is music no matter what!