The Daily Roxette discussions forum has been closed. The forum is only available as a read-only archive.
"Always breaking my heart"
33 replies
Roxly said on March 6, 2002 04:17:
Isn’t this song wonderful?
I found it in the net and from that time I can’t stop listening...!
It’s so obvious...
It’s Per writing wonderfully...unfortunately...there is no Merie singing like a goddess!
colinvdbel (moderator) said on March 6, 2002 05:24:
unfortunately? Per sings great!
You should hear the version from Belinda Carlisle.In that version, the band is roxette(including Per on backing vocals and guitar), and Belinda is singing.
m-cvk said on March 7, 2002 04:16:
I love that song! And I also like the BC-version, although Per said that he doesn’t like the BC-version.
Bye,
MC
dan-rox said on March 7, 2002 07:30:
such a sooooooooooooooo wonderfull song, do you have it or just listen at this ?
dan-rox said on March 7, 2002 07:32:
such a sooooooooooooooo wonderfull song, do you have it or just listen at this ?
bluesue said on March 7, 2002 07:33:
Love that song....and it’s recorded on Marie’s birthday.....very funny indeed
little-miss-sorrow said on March 7, 2002 07:51:
One of my faves. “Go get down on your knees and prayhayhay...” ;o)
deja_vu said on March 7, 2002 16:34:
i got many deadlinks from the russian stuff’s site, POR, and mp3 stars, where can i download ABMH again??
Pikappa said on March 9, 2002 00:17:
On AG is quite easy to find.
By the way the BC version rocks more than Per’s
I wish i could listen to something in this style in the next Rox album.
Igor_M said on March 9, 2002 00:26:
Per’s version -
http://roxette2.newmail.ru/always_breaking_my_heart.mp3
For me Belinda’s version this song much better then Per
frodi said on March 9, 2002 05:07:
Yeah it’s a damn good song. And if you like it you should pay some attention to the song Love dosen’t live here and Blue umbrella.
C’ ya’ round!
Igor_M said on March 10, 2002 00:46:
Love dosen’t live here (Per’s version, also was written for Belinda) - http://roxdisco.narod.ru/mp3/ldlh.tdsn
Blue umbrella -
http://www.joyroxette.boom.ru/blueumb.tdsn
Igor_M said on March 16, 2002 21:33:
Versions of Belinda Carlisle:
Always breaking my heart - http://roxette9.mailru.com/always_bc.tdsn
Love doesn’t live here - http://roxdisco.narod.ru/mp3/ldlh_bc.tdsn
After downloanig rename *.tdsn=*.mp3
enjoy!
mediamaffia said on September 15, 2005 12:07:
Sorry to bring this topic back again but somehow I missed these tracks...
Anyone know where I can find them? Prefer Per’s versions but also woul dlike to hear Belinda’s versions too
xx
ditroia said on September 15, 2005 14:02:
I believe that “Love Doesn’t Live Here” Was written for TWATG but never used, [Personally I don’t think it fits the album] as the version released is a completed recording not a demo. I think ABMH was also going to be included on TWATG. Why Per decided to give Belinda the songs I don’t know. Maybe it was EMI’s Idea.
I read an article about the whole thing once that explains most of it.
Dave
P.S. Per’s version of ABMH Rocks, but the lyrics aren’t as good as BC’s version.
Igor_M said on September 15, 2005 14:54:
LDLH & ABMH was written by Per specially for Belinda, they both told about it. And this collaboration was inspired by EMI.
Alesvenska said on September 15, 2005 21:43:
I do Love this song! it would have been a great hit sung by Marie!
AURYTE said on September 21, 2005 04:51:
I like Belinda’s version of Always Breaking My Heart very much :)
EmEx said on October 2, 2005 16:23:
the links dont work anywhere else i can get pers version?
the version of the women i have which is ok but not totally impressive who is that women anyways? sorry for being ignorant
ditroia said on October 4, 2005 06:15:
IGOR, I read an interview with Per Stating that both songs were supposed to be on his upcomming solo album, but were then given to BC.
Dave
Igor_M said on October 5, 2005 17:54:
David, I don’t remember where I read Per’s statement about these songs (maybe in FC reviews) but I’m sure he told he wrote them for Belinda, not for his solo album.
I doubt he was thinking about his solo album in English in ’95 - it was Roxette era.
girl7twenty7 said on October 17, 2005 11:54:
Fantastic song, love both Per’s and Belinda’s versions with a smaall preference of author’s demo :)
Quote: “it would have been a great hit sung by Marie”.
I think Marie’s voice doesn’t fit it, “Love doesn’t live here” would fit her much better...
ditroia said on October 21, 2005 03:47:
Toldya
Question:
Hello Per!
I’ve heard your song ’Love doesn’t live here’ and I absolutely love
it! Where is it from? Is it yours or Roxette’s? Will Roxette ever be
together again, esp live (preferably in England)?
Answer:
Love doesn’t live here was written and recorded for my THE WORLD
ACCORDING TO GOOFY-album back in 96. But my version was really
terrible (the demo was so much better!) so I gave it to Belinda
Carlisle who recorded it on one of her albums.
Dave
realsuga said on October 22, 2005 07:55:
I big heart the Belinda songs.....well, I just lurve Berlinder (altho I met her once and she was rude!). I do think the production of ABMY could have been better tho.....the handclaps are too faint and it’s almost too guitary......however that being said, it still outrox most songs in the charts. Love Doen’t Live Here tho is most excellent. Adore it......adore that whole album actually. One of Berlinder’s finer moments.
James_Earp said on October 24, 2005 16:39:
This song is in my opinion the best one Per has ever made....it is a big shame that it was Belinda and not Roxette who got it....but as long as I have my “Do you wanna be my baby” singel I will survive.
roxcyn said on November 10, 2005 11:38:
I finally got her album :D. I like it a lot to actually have the CD that I wanted for so long :D
bbrox said on December 23, 2005 23:01:
I prefer the demo of Per!!! It really rox! ;-)
I just made a collection of the b-sides and demos from the TWATG singles and other songs, and I just have to say “Always breaking my heart” is a perfect album opener! :-)
Roxly said on March 6, 2002 04:25:
typing mistake... “Marie”