purplemedusa said on October 27, 2004 04:42:

Shame... Judith is such a honey - what could ppl actually have against her?

Susi said on October 27, 2004 05:51:

@lerina74: People speaking BADLY of JUDITH can only be idiots. Just had to say that cuz she is one of the most helpful and nicest person I know!!!!

Ferdan said on October 27, 2004 06:44:

They can express their opinions all they want, there´s nothing wrong with that, you lerina are *annoying*, just my opinion, see ;)

But it´s a shame they´ve done it in a way that doesn´t look too professional you know, and twice a shame for being in the frontpage.

*replaced word, the original was “bitch” ;)

Ferdan said on October 27, 2004 06:51:

ok, i´ll edit that for a”lighter” word.

*anyway*
There´s a good thing on TDR’s front page, and that thing is that TDR is the source for many online newspapers around the world. it´s a shame that many sites that won´t be able to have a copy of the album are going to get an impression from the front page /official/ reviews.

per_mson said on October 27, 2004 07:29:

@lerina74: As Susi said... if you have ever heard anything bad about Judith I can assure you those people are most likely idiots and jealous fools. Don’t ever believe in such rumours. Judith is a great person and is the most generous Roxettefan I have ever met! So if you jump on her you jump on me!

ally77 said on October 27, 2004 07:34:

Awwww 3 BIG cheers, for Judith! she’s great.... and who is this silly person flaming her... what on earth could Judith have done to deserve such a topic...

I think I see the grey coming.... :)

per_mson said on October 27, 2004 07:36:

@Ferdan: So you mean that TDR should write glorifying words about an album no matter what they think just so other sites should think it is a great one?! Isn’t that a really weird way to think?!
When I read reviews I first of all don’t trust one of them. I want to read more. Secondly I wonder why they won’t get an impression from the front page? There are even three opinions there!! And as I said in another thread: Reviews are ALWAYS build on opinions. There is no such thing as an objective review.

m-cvk said on October 27, 2004 07:37:

If you don’t want to listen to (how is that possible on a PC-forum? ), so ’read’ is better, her (or anybody’s) opinion: JUST DON’T READ IT!

And in case you didn’t know: everybody has his/her right to give his/her opinion and you don’t have to agree with his/her opinion. And I (and as you can see, I’m not the only one) DON’T agree with your opinion.

Ferdan said on October 27, 2004 07:56:

As I said in the front page, you can have in a review objectivity and opinion, as long as it is looks clearly defined and but with a careful choice of words.

I´m not saying the frontpage review should be all praise to Marie. I´m just saying it should be a more “pleasant” read, even if it doesn´t have good things to tell about the album. The choice of words have been unnecesarily harsh, in my opinion. Too Ferdan-esque ;)
What I call “objectivity” also falls into the target of public the review was written for, I think it should have been written with a “general public” in mind, and not with something that seemed written to the TDR regular guys.

ally77 said on October 27, 2004 08:11:

What you gotta except is people have different opinions...

Rich-UK said on October 27, 2004 08:30:

I’m with Pietro on this one! Time to stop flaming and quibbling. Peace. Rich

PS In case it’s not deleted...(!)... Judith has been really helpful to me on 2 occasions: (1) helping me get a refund from roxette.nl for undelivered goods, and (2) helping me to find an elusive Brainpool album: thanks / gracias / tack!

ATLTK said on October 27, 2004 09:26:

@per i´m with you totally.
y no jud no es una mala persona ella es una persona muy amable y muy agradable y muy muy bueno.
no aceptó cuando algunas personas se dicen “ella es una persona ma,la” porque eso no es verdad!!!

in english
and no judith isn´t a bad person shes kind and very very very nice. I don´t accept when some people says she´s a bad person!