Great "Room Service" review!
roxtexanet said on February 13, 2002 07:26:
Has anyone else seen this??! I think this is a really good, really fair review of this album that captures the spirit of it perfectly. And it’s in the “All Music Guide”, too!
Roxette / Room Service (Apr 3, 2001). AMG EXPERT REVIEW: If proof were needed that Roxette are the new Abba, the lack of critical respect should be enough. Like Abba, Roxette is a masterful pop band (with just the right amount of kitsch in its armor) that routinely gets slagged off for lacking substance, whatever that may be. Room Service showcases a band at the top of its form with its feet firm on the pedal: this album is a case study in songcraft and pop smarts. With its na-na-na choruses and sparkly guitars, Room Service is also trademark Roxette, a mostly no-surprises package that divides its time between the soaring, emotive power ballads and the rife-with-hooks rock-dance stompers that the band pretty much took patents out on back in the ’80s and ’90s. This is a group that has gotten really good at what it is doing, without getting bored doing it. Result? Probably the best Roxette album since Joyride. Opening tracks “Real Sugar” and “The Centre of the Heart” with their now-rock, now-disco, always-pop attack are effortless up-tempo smashes that deliver an unstoppable one-two sucker punch. On the other hand, “Milk and Toast and Honey” and “Bringing Me Down to My Knees” are big-ticket slow-burners that are as good as adult contemporary gets. “Try (Just a Little Bit Harder)” burgles the “Just a little bit” refrain from Aretha Franklin’s “Respect” and uses it to spike the sort of lush, half-pensive ballad that Roxette can toss off in its sleep by now. “You Make My Heart Go Pop” is a noisy, overproduced Top-Ten-here-we-come sparkler that’ll zoom straight to the trash-magnet center of your brain and stick there for weeks on end. This album also shows a lyrically sharper Roxette, less eager than before to compromise the words for the hooks. Sure, they may occasionally slip into cliché and overt sentimentalism, but they’re never less than tuneful. Both Per Gessle and Marie Frederiksson are in fine vocal form, especially Marie, who’s equally proficient whether she’s doing elegiac laments or burning the house down. Room Service is an exciting, immediate, high-gloss pop gem that contains very little filler indeed.
daniel_alv said on February 13, 2002 11:03:
Yeah.... why don’t they release one more single from RS.... They have had three hits so far....
Buko said on February 13, 2002 12:16:
Certainly it is a great review, although I couldn’t understand everything that was said about Matah and BMDTMK.
I just don’t agree with “RS is the best album since Joyride”, cause I still find HAND a little bit better. Maybe because COY, WICF and Stars became great songs to me.
chantie_ said on February 13, 2002 13:02:
its all about opninions, isnt it. the whole world goes around opinions. here in holland TCOTH and MATAH did NOTHING and they didnt even bother to release real sugar because emi thought it wouldnt ’be right for holland’.....
holland + roxette = unthinkable
so much for ’they had 3 hits’.... let them concentrate on new stuff, i’d say.
coyboyusa said on February 14, 2002 03:36:
hand was a better album rs seems more like a left overs albumalmost like a rarities 2 sometimes to me..i hope the next album is more commercial like hand
Ferdan said on February 14, 2002 04:43:
HAND SUCKS
if you care about commercial stuff why dont you buy BSB or Britney?
I mean, is it important if an album is commercial or not? I think it’s more important if it has better music or not... and well.... a big majority thinks HAND doesnt have the best of roxette.... at all
SilverBloo said on February 14, 2002 04:48:
Wow.
Beats seven shades out of the review Channel 4 (UK)’s Planet Sound teletext pages gave it:
”...I feel sick. 1/10.”
SB
Sascha said on February 14, 2002 10:51:
Roxette’s songs carry emotions. Either you hate it or loooove it! If critics want to appear cool they pull it down.
erweetiran said on February 14, 2002 21:25:
The most popular south african magazine said last year that Room Service will be the best pop you will hear that year
erweetiran said on February 14, 2002 21:37:
FERDAN are you insane? Are you telling me roxette is not trying to write commercial stuff like Britney and BSB? Of course they are! listen to Stars, COY, Centre! commercial stuff is what it is all about these days, you either play the game, or go home! Thats why Looking for Jane wan’t released and thats why Jefferson wansn’t released. Hand was a much better album than Room Service, There is much more going on, much more happening and much more ideas put into the HAND songs than in room service, face it!
Small-talker said on February 18, 2002 02:41:
I’M SO SICK OF REVIEWS...Just listen to the reviews which someone here showed us ... “...i feel sick 1/10”
I’D LOVE TO GATHER EVERY SINGLE CRITIC AND SHOVE THEM ALL INTO THE HUGEST FIRE AND LET THEM ALL BURN IN HELL FOR ALL ETERNITY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHHAHAHHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHAH (that will be me laughing at their rotting/burning corpses
SilverBloo said on February 18, 2002 04:27:
@_@°
That’s the last time I give you a can of Red Bull, dude...
SB
Ferdan said on February 18, 2002 04:37:
well erwe..... I almost lost the faith in Roxette because of songs like Stars or TCOTH.
I like Roxette because of songs like Silver Blue, Things will never.... It takes you no time.... and more, songs that are not so commercial but musically great.... cos I only care about music above commercial succes.
SilverBloo said on February 18, 2002 05:03:
Shame that, Ferdan, because it seems the music industry bigwigs are the exact opposite.
SB
tevensso (moderator) said on February 13, 2002 09:24:
Very good review indeed! Too bad Rox and EMI don’t care enough to promote their work...