The Daily Roxette discussions forum has been closed. The forum is only available as a read-only archive.
WICF vs ATAY
26 replies
DTR24 said on September 30, 2002 13:15:
Hi friends.
I love ATAY and of course WICF !!
But dont you think that both are in the same stile scored and arranged ?
What do you think ?
Greetings Dany
Iris said on September 30, 2002 19:08:
I agree with Martin_Nl .. WICF was sooo much better than ATAY.
I loved WICF .. it had something really special and all the atmosphere of the song fit perfect to the season ... i loved it to play it really loud ... that was a fantastic song ... so much better than ATAY .. well, at least I like ATAY .. but it’s not great.
Kiwein1 said on September 30, 2002 19:08:
Maybe you are right!
But I think that WICF is more powerful!
wendy said on September 30, 2002 19:43:
Okay,i know,WICF is better then ATAY,but i think they sounds a bit similair :s
Santi said on September 30, 2002 19:47:
They sound alike a lot... even the videos look alike a lot. Well, except for that in this one Per even appears.
coyboyusa said on September 30, 2002 21:57:
wicgf is an entirely different song it will have charted better than atoy
Santi said on October 1, 2002 08:54:
@coyboyusa: Why do you always call it “atoy”? Do you mean “a toy” or something?
DTR24 said on October 1, 2002 11:36:
No ATAY means the short form from A Thing About You. You just take the first letter of the song titel. It’s much easier and faster to tipe it in the thread.
So WICF is Wish I Could Fly
or the HAND Album is just Have a nice day.
:-)
Greetings
Dany
p.s Now playing ATAY
DTR24 said on October 1, 2002 12:00:
And I got a thing about ATAY !
It’s a really lovely ballad.
And it’S painting my world blue :-))
Greetings Dany
gargar said on October 2, 2002 14:15:
i love them both.... maybe wicf a little more... just little.i hope roxette will never stop making this kind of music. the only good pop exist
bunny said on October 3, 2002 05:40:
i think WICF is a better song and has better arragements like the nice cello and beats in the beginning. ATAY is not bad, just not on the same level as WICF. I would say WICF is a A song from Roxette, ATAY is a B+/A-.
exceland said on October 3, 2002 12:28:
A Thing About you! I love it! I even have a new e-mail adress: [email protected]!
Nefatari said on October 3, 2002 12:59:
ATAY is much better than WICF ...
I didn’t like WICF at all (and still don’t like it), but I loved ATAY from the first second of listening to it.
And it seems, ppl at radiostation would agree with me, they play ATAY a lot of times.
So I’m sure, ATAY is gonna be a hit, which never happened to WICF in Austria.
coyboyusa said on October 3, 2002 16:23:
lol atoy is my typo shame on me
i love the song but without marie there to promote the song dint get me wrong i love per...the song isnt gonna chart as well as wicf..besides wicf is technically a power ballad...not in the classic sense but it still is
RealSugarSexMagick said on October 5, 2002 08:09:
I don’t think they sound the same at all. One’s so much more powerful, the other more acoustically arranged. I’d compare ’ATAY’ more towards ’It Takes You No TimeTo Get Here’. At least in the verses and bridges. Wish is more in the same styles as ’You Don’t Understand Me’ and ’Spending My Time’. Don’t ya think?
wendy said on September 30, 2002 18:30:
Yeps,i also do think they are similar to eachother,but that’s why it’s gonna be a hit ;)