The Daily Roxette discussions forum has been closed. The forum is only available as a read-only archive.
Who here has the biggest Madonna Collection?
34 replies
Nefatari said on April 5, 2002 12:19:
@Ferdan
You’re right, for you or me, this discussion is somehow like nonsense ... and those who are interested in topics like that are discussing at the wrong place.
But there is a Roxette-fan who seems to want to talk to other Roxette-fans about his/hers big Madonna-collection.
Actually I don’t have a problem with that. And I guess, we’re all in no position to judge if it is worthy or not :)
Vixzter said on April 3, 2002 21:10:
Biggest Madonna collection??
You, otherwise you probably wouldn’t have written this topic.
Markuz said on April 4, 2002 01:35:
*agrees with Vix*
BTW, I have the girlie show DVD and I must say it’s great.
tevensso (moderator) said on April 4, 2002 08:05:
I have one single in total. But really, how interesting is it?
Who here has the biggest Cliff Richard collection? :)
richkoni said on April 4, 2002 10:18:
sorry
21 albums
41 singles
6 dvd’s of which to DVDsingles
3 video’s
4 books
i am a huge madonna fan, though i have to confess.... at the roxette concerts i had much more fun....
richkoni said on April 4, 2002 10:20:
BTW do you have the song guilty by association... that’s really cool..... together with her brother in law.....
Small-talker said on April 4, 2002 11:22:
@ richkoni...
are you sure you’re a real fan? Madonna never released 21 albums*... the rest could be true
And i didn’t understand what you said about guilty of association... Madonna never made a song with her brother in law, if that’s what you mean....
* She released 16...(which I have)
The 16 are....
1 Madonna - The First Album
2 Like A Virgin
3 True Blue
4 You Can Dance
5 Who’s That Girl
6 Like A Prayer
7 I’m Breathless (Music from & Inspired by the feature film Dick Tracy)
8 The Immaculate Collection
9 Erotica
10 Bedtime Stories
11 Something To Remember
12 Evita
13 Ray Of Light
14 Music
15 Music (Special Edition)
16 GHV2
Do you have all of them at least???
Nefatari said on April 4, 2002 12:04:
I have all the Madonna-albums, some singles, some Japan-exports, 2 VHS and 1 DVD .... but I’ve never been a fanatic Madonna-lover (had no time for that, because of ... you know who *lol* ).
2 years ago I saw her in a Show on TV, she was sooooo .... well, since then I don’t like her anylonger .....
(There is a big difference between Per&Marie and Madonna ... Per&Marie are really lovely persons!)
Anyway, wish ya much fun with Madonna :)
Stormkeeper said on April 4, 2002 17:39:
Small-talker: don´t forget ‘Early Years‘ album.
There are also some interview disc´s.
She´s the best-looking over 40-year old female I know! :)
Used to be a huge fan in the ‘80´s but lost interest.
But sure STR is one of my best cd‘s.
Her movies are terrible. *sorry* Didn´t like even Evita.
richkoni said on April 4, 2002 19:52:
i never said it were all different albums...
i have the two evita versions
all 4 music versions (normal, pink, grey and double)
digi pack version of ray of light
booket version of GHV2
i have a few bootleg albums as well
and for your information madonna recorded ’guilty by association’ together with het brother in law, joe henry, for the sweet relief 2 album (which i also have got by the way). it was released in 1996 by columbia records.....
try a search engine like bearshare if you still don’t believe me or just look it up in some discography....
do you also know ’if you forget me’, ’supernatural’ and ’freedom’?
Vixzter said on April 4, 2002 20:40:
I don’t own any Madonna stuff, oh what a freak I am ;)
Anyway.....Madge isn’t the only good looking over 40 female I know *looks in the general direction of Sweden*
Ferdan said on April 4, 2002 21:27:
don’t discuss about who has the biggest Madonna collection here...... i bet you have hundreds of hyperpopulated forums to talk about things like that...
We have enough childish discussion with Rox :)))
Ferdan said on April 4, 2002 22:33:
@stormkeeper
Look at Graciela Alfano.... she’s 42 in this pic..... now she’s close to 50..... and remains the same :)
http://usuarios.lycos.es/fanalfano/graciela8.jpg
richkoni said on April 5, 2002 09:46:
why we are duscussing madonna?!
maybe because back in ’91 per said in every interview mary was much sexier than madonna was on stage.... and well madonna has proven something roxette unfortunately still haven’t.... that doesn’t mean i think roxette is crap... i listen to roxette every day and really really love them!!
all we are trying to do here is trying to have something in common with people from all over the world that like roxette. sometimes is roxette-related but it is cool to find out other similarities like being form a country, been at a certain place being gay or liking madonna for instance. what is bad about that!?
Nefatari said on April 5, 2002 09:54:
@richkoni
I just can talk about my opinion!
And I don’t find anything bad about talking about some other similarities than Roxette.
Roxette are very important to me, but they ain’t anything. There happens much more in my life than Roxette :)
(It would be sad, if I would just live for Roxette. It would mean: living for one autumn, waiting and suffering for about 4 years. No no, that’s not enough for me! :) )
tevensso (moderator) said on April 5, 2002 10:13:
OK, to make this slightly relevant; Madonna was one of Roxette’s major influences back in ’86 (together with ABBA, Eurythmics and The Cars). True.
Yashar said on April 5, 2002 10:16:
I can’t understand why are you discussing about
Madonna here,in this page.
It’s not bad to talk about the others,but not here.
Nefatari said on April 5, 2002 10:59:
Why do you wonder, why some are discussing ’bout something else than Roxette?
At least it was you who opened the thread “Is there a band which you like more than Roxette?” ... The subject is very similar to the discussion in this thread!
Just my opinion :)
Ferdan said on April 5, 2002 12:01:
Well.... I¨m not saying you can’t discuss about madonna here...... i´m saying don’t discuss about STUPID THINGS like “who has the biggest madonna collection” in here.
arnie said on April 5, 2002 15:23:
I have all her albums except
-Ray of light
-Evita
-GHV2
Tapes & cd’s, all of them are original releases.
And I also have the MOST HORRIBLE album she’s ever recorded: ... “Give it to me” feautiring Cosmic climb, give it to me, we are the gods.... oh pathetic!
Have you heard it? It sucks!!!
Stormkeeper said on April 5, 2002 19:39:
arnie: I have this same album as a tape but my version is called Early Years. You are right: it´s intolerable.
Ferdan said on April 5, 2002 20:42:
Argentinean actress...... now maybe the cutest over40 you’ve seen now :))
Mfan28179-Jason said on April 6, 2002 06:41:
LOL. It’s funny how some of you complain about a topic like this being brought up. I say as long as there’s not fighting going on here, what is wrong with it? If you don’t like Madonna or don’t care to read any other’s interests in her, then don’t bother clicking the link to the topic. Maybe it’s just me, but sometimes I think people are out to get an argument started. There’s too much criticism of other people here and their topics. Some people may find it interesting. Some may not.
Ferdan said on April 6, 2002 14:46:
stoop....
What is not clear? Talking about Madonna is an interesting topic... but not childish discussion about the biggest collection.... i call it childish cos they were discussing the amount of released albums and stuff... BUT like searching a thing to dismiss each other’s collection
We hace enough childish discussion with Rox...
Small-talker said on April 6, 2002 16:05:
@ Rickhoni...
I can’t be bothered with bootleg albums...
I have enough ’discographies’ thank you...
I have heard all the B-Sides
I don’t like all her films...
I’m actually talking ’bout albums... not a Pink or Blue version of Music...
@ Everyone else
And isn’t it wierd that only the first few replies are about the actual topic...
If you don’t like Madonna... then don’t read this topic... Is that so much to ask???...
Small-talker said on April 6, 2002 16:10:
@ Storm-keeper
The ‘early years‘ album is not by Madonna... she only sang Back-up vocals on that... They’re actually by Ottomen(or something like that)
Madonna’s early band... idiot!
Nefatari said on April 6, 2002 18:35:
@small talker
huu, so friendly ... you’re really fast, calling someone idiot! that’s nice!
coyboyusa said on April 7, 2002 01:50:
ok here is the deal with madonna i will admitt liking her..especially her last 2 albums, but madonna has never really been her own artist, she grabs a little known trend exposes it and burries it..techno, electronica dance etc. her only original album was erotica..which had its own sound and sensuality.....roxette on the other hand have stayed true to their form, they aren’t pretentipus and don’t need sex to sell millions of albums....
Oliver said on April 7, 2002 16:38:
I´m sure I haven´t got the biggest Madonna Collection. I only have the 4 CD´s of the MUSIC Mix 2001 collection which I bought on a record fair in Austria two years ago.
I didn´t listen to them since months so I wanted to sell them at ebay, but they cancelled the auction, because the CD´s are only for DJ´s and not intended for the public. That´s funny.
Small-talker said on April 8, 2002 17:51:
Can you please tell me the names of all the non-album tracks...like ’Guilty By Association’ or ’Goodbye To Innocence’...
I’d like to download all the songs like that as the ones I have are so great...
Here are the ones I have... (or the ones in my Audiogalaxy Q)
Cyber-Raga
Each Time You Break My Heart*
Family Affair
Fantasy*
Freedom*
Gaitish
Gambler
Goodbye To Innocence
Guilty By Association
I‘ve Always Been In Love With You*
If You forget me*
Santa Baby
Supernatural
Safe Neighbourhood*
* = Are songs that I don’t know for sure are by Madonna - you know what file-sharing systems are like... you get some idiot that doesn’t know the name of a song and they just write down what they think is correct... (I once spent an hour downloading a Natalie Imbruglia called ’Bubbles Of Love’ only to find out that it was actually one of her biggest hits ’Big Mistake’...(they must have got the name from the bridge when she says ’think of all the bubbles of love we made’)
Small-talker said on April 8, 2002 18:22:
Can you tell me... on your Ray Of Light how many songs are there??
I have the version with 13 songs... but I seen on http://www.wbr.com/madonna before it was converted to GHV2 that it had 14 songs and I forget the name of the song... the track-listing is like this...
1 - 12 remain the same
13 = the new track
14 Mer Girl
Does anyone know the name of that track?
Stormkeeper said on April 13, 2002 18:37:
@small-talker:
watch your words you little bitch. I´m not surprised you´re still at school and you´re 15.
Small-talker said on April 3, 2002 18:04:
I think I do...
I have...
16 Albums
40 Singles
3 DVDs
2 Books
& The Justify My Love VHS (Video)
... And out of all the songs she’s made I only haven’t heard ’Goodbye To Innocence’... which I’m gonna download now (btw, this is my first time downloading a Madonna song as I’ve been lucky enough to find all the singles of the rare stuff (B-Sides & such...)
Just wondering if anyone can beat that